Bob Beck on August 7th, 2011

A Pilot Electronic Medical Record

Lawrence Loh, MD MPH CCFP

 

In a previous blog post, we discussed the possibility of developing an electronic medical record for La Romana. During our trip last year, we trialed a tracking system which involved both paper records that were stored by the hospital linked to an Excel spreadsheet that was organized by a unique patient identification number. This identification number, in turn, was linked to a photograph of the patient in question, stored with the Excel spreadsheet, and also linked to a paper record, which was stored at Good Samaritan for review by future teams. This provided two records – aggregate data for research stored in a locked Excel file, and paper records for each patient’s individual continuity of care.

Sample Spreadsheet Attached.

 

In creating a unique patient identification number, we attempted to overcome one of the biggest difficulties in creating an electronic medical record in La Romana—ensuring that the same record would travel with the same batey resident. Given the nature of our work in the bateyes, we attempted to develop a record system that would maximize the chance that records would follow individual patients.

 

We came up with a numbering system that followed the format YY-S-NNNNN. YY represented the last two digits of the year that the patient was enrolled; S was 0 for males and 1 for females, and NNNNN represented the number assigned to that patient at enrolment, sequential with each subsequent patient. Thus, the first female that we enrolled in the database had the number 10-1-00001; similarly, a male code might be 10-0-00302.

 

Setting up a traditional clinic in the bateyes, we followed patients through the process as they registered, were measured and placed in the waiting area, seen by one of our physicians, and dispensed medications. At the entrance to the clinic, patients were registered as above. We created a booklet with the above serial number noted, and took a photo of the patient. Within each booklet, we sought to fully complete the patient’s name and aliases, which batey they were from, and their home phone number and maternal tongue. Each clinic day ended with the creation of an Excel file listing all these details.

 

We kept a list of patient names and serial numbers, and recorded file names of the photos corresponding to each. Physicians then used the yellow cards to record the cause of the visit along with any medications prescribed and the doses used. The pharmacy volunteers then took these yellow cards and booklets, and double checked the completeness of the information before dispensing the medications.

 

At the end of each clinic day, we manually entered the information from the booklets and yellow cards into an Excel file. This file linked each line to an individual patient, their identification number, their corresponding photo, and the reasons for their visit and treatments received.

 

This system, as developed, had the potential to overcome a number of problems. Firstly, with regards to ongoing records safeguarding, the storage and keeping of the records by Good Samaritan Hospital meant that many of the batey residents would have a file upon their next visit from another team. At the same time, the use of a unique identification number and a biometric such as a photograph contributed to that continuity of care while carefully linking each record to a specific batey resident.

 

The manual entry of data, while seemingly tedious, did have its own benefits as well. It allowed standardization of diagnoses, which, in the context of the Excel sheet, provided valuable data as to what were the key reasons batey patients were seeking care from our clinic. It also allowed us to review each photograph, linking it to a specific record, and ensuring that each booklet represented a unique record that corresponded to a recorded line in the Excel file. We should consider to a proper electronic medical record, with equipment, could streamline this process by allowing entry and linking at the point of care.

 

The existing system posed a number of challenges for the benefits it provided—it required an additional time and work commitment from clinic staff, particularly with the taking of the photos and ensuring that all the information was properly filled out; it also required an additional time commitment at the end of the day for further data entry. Another challenge of the system, as it existed, was the recording of ongoing visits. While our plan was to have each visit recorded as a new line or entry with the Excel file and to pass the Excel file on to each subsequent team, we were acutely aware that not all teams go to the same bateyes.

 

What we did glean, however, is that any future electronic medical record in La Romana should ensure continuity within the database. In that sense, biometrics like photographs and fingerprints should be considered for use and linked to a specific personal identification number. Each identification number should also be linked to the individual’s record, which can either be hard copy or electronic, and stored by the hospital (similar to a chart) to reduce the responsibility required for people to hold their own records in the batey setting.

 

As a next step, we should collectively examine possible platforms and electronic solutions that address these needs and that may serve as tools for Good Samaritan in La Romana.

 

Lawrence Loh is a family and urgent care physician from Toronto, Canada. He is specialising in public health and preventive medicine at the University of Toronto and is a graduate of the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. He has been going to La Romana annually for the last few years as a co-founder of the Pluribus Network, a non-profit organization based out of New York.

 


(Contains 1 attachments.)

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

  • Share/Bookmark
Bob Beck on July 28th, 2011

An Electronic Medical Record for La Romana?

Lawrence Loh, MD MPH CCFP

One of the biggest complexities in health care, even in the developed world, is continuity of care, especially among providers. Many health conditions are not strictly acute, but develop over years, such as adult-onset diabetes, high blood pressure, and obesity. Coordinating monitoring and treatment efforts serves to prevent diseases from beginning in the first place, and reduces the harms associated with disease progression and treatment side-effects once the condition has been identified.
Health care in the bateyes often occurs with a short-term time scale and vision, given the nature of many of our medical outreach trips in La Romana. However, the problems that plague the people of the bateyes are deeper systemic issues—low education, poor hygiene practices, limited access to adequate and nutritious food and water. It follows that many of the health problems treated on a short time scale only reflect these underlying long-term issues. Chopping off the tip of the iceberg during our week down there only means that the tip will grow back six months later. To accomplish long-term health outcomes for patients – in any setting, but especially in the bateyes – we need to improve the “picture” we have of our patients there.
As such, the short-time scales point to the first of many benefits that an Electronic Medical Record could provide for individual patients. Many of our decisions are based on knowing patients, but realistically, how well do we know any of the batey residents that we see once or twice a year? Presently, there’s little interconnection between the teams that do go down, and hence, no way for us to identify and monitor certain patients. An EMR would allow an at-a-glance triage, avoiding irrelevancies in our interactions with patients and providing health care on identified priorities for each individual.
A second benefit is data. Monitoring the chief reasons for visits to batey clinics would help us to better plan what medications and treatment interventions to bring. It would also give us greater opportunity to plan educational campaigns and decide what public health measures could be collectively implemented by all of us working in La Romana. Once such measures are implemented, ongoing data could be collected to evaluate the outcomes of such efforts.
We could also link EMRs to the internet and allow us to monitor from abroad. Thinking even more broadly, with the data piece, we would have an idea remotely what supplies might be needed for the diseases seen regularly in mobile batey clinics. If this information were provided as real-time forecasts on a common internet website, teams would be able to work in securing medicines deemed “essential” long before their actual trip.
Of course, there are numerous challenges to the implementation of EMRs. One of the many that have been identified includes the actual organizational logistics behind such an undertaking. How do we reconcile the information with the yellow cards? Do we bring laptops or tablet PCs out with us, where there is no electricity available and no support if there are technical issues? Are there back-ups? Do we provide corresponding paper records to the patients for them to keep, or do we store them ourselves? What is the best way to track patients – providing individual “health card numbers”, or perhaps linking biometric measures such as photographs or fingerprints to electronic health records?
Beyond that is the additional commitment of resources. Many of the teams that go down are already skeleton crews of good-hearted volunteers. How much of an additional administrative burden will this add? Will the additional burden of administration be offset by the benefits of the information and the improved efficiency of care provided in the bateyes?
Finally, a last challenge that needs to be considered is involving all the teams. If even a few teams choose not to participate, the benefits of the system diminish significantly. Further to that, priorities need to be agreed upon by all the teams. If a few teams decide to start monitoring hypertension in the adult population and other decide that is not a priority, the coordination of medication supplies and ongoing monitoring becomes that much more difficult. Building consensus and agreement will require all teams to be involved in sharing their vision for a shared system and platform to benefit the batey residents.
A number of discussions have arisen between our group and teams at the University of Massachusetts and Yale University. While the logistics are yet to be worked out, there is a growing consensus that the implementation of a hospital-wide EMR should be considered. These will allow all of us to take our patient’s stories, turning them  into tangible health benefits, with all of us working on monitoring and fixing the underlying health problems.
Our next blog post will describe a possible structure that our team put together during our last trip down, and discuss the pros and cons of such a system.
Lawrence Loh is a family and urgent care physician from Toronto, Canada. He is specialising in public health and preventive medicine at the University of Toronto and is a graduate of the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. He has been going to La Romana annually for the last few years as a co-founder of the Pluribus Network, a non-profit organization based out of New York.

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

  • Share/Bookmark
Bob Beck on July 15th, 2011

I am organizing a trip for next February.  So far there are about 25 people registered.  I have reserved 35 seats on a Jet Blue Flight from JFK non-stop to Santo Doming.  I’m looking to fill the available seats before July 24th when I will confirm the reservations.

 

I have attached a registration form.  If you are interested in joining us please respond quickly.  Sorry for the short notice.

 

Bob Beck


(Contains 1 attachments.)

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

  • Share/Bookmark
Bob Beck on May 16th, 2011

Sooooooooooooooo? If the title says Good Sam Social Services why are you looking at the earthquake damage again? Isn’t that old news? If we were talknig about Haiti, or if the newly elected President, Michel ‘Sweet Micky’ Martelly, it would be new news. But that’s not what we’re talking about.
Following the earthquake many of us were wondering what the effects would be on the DR and particularily the bateys. In April 2010, three months after the earthquake, I was in La Romana with a mission team. I asked, as I’m sure many of you did also, if the earthquake brought a lot of Haitians into the cane fileds. I was surprised to learn that there was little impact at all.
This year it’s a different story. This April I was with Emilio in the batey Solano. Solano is about three miles from Lechuga. We were there distributing clothing that had been donated by our churches back home. We had 100 family packs to distribute and they evaporated. Emilio explained that recently the batey had doubled in size. This was because of the ‘normal’ process of bateys being combined into larger communities but Emilio also mentioned that the number of people in the bateyes has significantly increased since the earthquake. Solano is not the only batey that has been rebuilt. In February I was out in the eastern batey of Guazuma and found it has more than doubled in size.
Last March the number of patients seen by the medical teams set new records. In April we visited a ‘small’ batey near Lechuga expecting to see fewer than 50 patients. We actually saw about 80.
With the census in the bateyes increasing there is more demand for support services from the hospital. Our already stretched resources are becoming more difficult to manage. The lifline of duffel bags we have been carrying with us for twenty years has been cut in half by new airline baggage restrictions. To bring two checked bags per team member now increases the cost of the trip by $1,000.00 or more depending on the airline. It may be better to publish a price list for the medications we need and bring the necessary funds to purchase them in La Romana and have them waiting for us.
Programs that provide vitamins and other food suppliments to those needing it most will have to be reviewed and upgraded as needed. Programs to keep kids in school as well as provide education to young adults to prevent pregnacy and control the spread of STD’s may be expanded.
As more school children move from the schools nearby where they live and travel to a school in a larger batey transportation costs will increase. The transportation costs are about $20.00 a month per student, depending on how far they need to travel. We are trying to complete an addition to the school in Brador to eliminate these costs that are affecting three bateys in the immediate area.
Perhaps the hardest situation from the cane cutters point of view is the reduced pay they are receiving. Regardless of how many people there are to harvest the cane there is only so much cane to be harvested. Cutters are still receiving $120RD per ton they cut. Last year they were able to cut perhaps 5 or 6 tons a day, receiving as much as $720RD or about $20.00US a day. As we were bouncing along in the school bus on our way to Agua Blanco I saw a group of about twenty men sitting around near the scales. I asked Emilio what they were doing. He explaned because there are so many cutters they have to take turns filling the wagons. Sharing the work seems like a good idea but when you realize it probably cuts their pay in half it’s not something they like.
The situation I found in April will probably be around for some time to come. They may become worse before people can begin to earn a living in Haiti.

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

  • Share/Bookmark
Bob Beck on May 4th, 2011

Hi,

I just got back from La Romana.  The pizza was great.

The hospital is about to open the surgeries all of you have been working on this winter/spring.  Thank you for all your talent and efforts in pushing this project to competition.  Surgery groups from Kansas City, South Carolina, Michigan and other places will soon be healing people thanks to your efforts.  Thank You.

The project to rebuild Kelvin’s house has started.  One of the April teams got the footings poured and the walls up.  The work is about half done and funding is needed to complete the work.  We are trying to get the roof and floor in before the rainy season begins.  Read more on the web site www.laromana.org

Also on the web site are new was to contribute funds without writing checks.  Sound interesting?  Check it out.

Danny has designed a new T-shirt to help raise funds for Kelvin’s house.  Info is on the web.

The church is interested in purchasing the house/land adjacent to Casa Pastoral.  Right now plans are incomplete but they are asking for funds to get some legal work done.  More on this as they go forward.  Please help if you can.

It’s good to be home but I miss our friends in La Romana.

 

God bless,

Bob Beck

 

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

  • Share/Bookmark
Bob Beck on April 17th, 2011

Hi,

 

We have not been as successful as we hoped in gathering needed equipment for the hospital.  There is still time to send items you may know of but the container is only about half full. We are opening up the items to any that will be useful for the hospital.  This includes small items, crutches, walkers, wheelchairs, medical supplies that have not expired.  Items that you may have but will not fit into a suitcase or duffel bags.

SORRY, NO USED CLOTHING OR SHOES.  THEY WILL BE CONFISCATED BY DOMINICAN CUSTOMS.

To all who have searched for the items thank you.  To find any of them would be like striking gold.  This equipment is rarely available without the benefit of a long relationship between one of us and a hospital or clinic that is aware of the hospital in La Romana and the work it does.  That’s how we received the CT Scanner.  In service equipment is generally included in the marketing and sale of new equipment.  Just like trading in your old car.  The equipment used in the deal is quickly snatched up by used equipment dealers that refurbish the items and place them back on the market.

The equipment you are asked to locate is still very much in need at the hospital.  It is estimated to have a purchase price on the used equipment market of $100,000.00.  Please continue to search for these items.  We are looking for a place where we can store donations until there is enough to make a container shipment worth while.  We are also starting a fund for contributions towards purchasing these items.

Please contact me with any items you wish to donated.  Check the web site  at www.laromana.com for shipping information.

 

Thanks for trying,

God bless,

Bob Beck


Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

  • Share/Bookmark
Bob Beck on April 12th, 2011

Thank you for your response to the request to help locate a CR Reader.  We have several responses and are in the process of running down the leads.  Please keep looking because we have not yet secured one.

If you didn’t have any luck finding a CR Reader we have another opportunity for everyone.  We are looking for a 4D ultrasound machine.  Ultrasound has a special place in the history of Good Sam.  When the hospital was first opened there was an active Free Zone just a little north of the hospital.  At that time a woman had to show proof that she was not pregnant in order to be hired.  This turned out to be a boon for Good Sam because the only piece of diagnostic equipment we had was an ultrasound machine.  The hospital was offering the lowest priced ultrasound anywhere in the city.  For two years it contributed 20% to the hospital’s total revenues.  Today ultrasound remains one of the most profitable services provided. The number one reason for an ultrasound is still OBGYN.

Since the first days of the hospital the technology of ultrasound has advanced notably.  The current machine is a 1D unit and stepping up to a 4D unit is like going from black and white television to 3D as you can see in the picture shown here.  4D Ultrasound has been available in the United States since at least 2007 so there should be some used units in a closet somewhere in a clinic.  Perhaps a clinic or hospital where you live.  Please check them out and let us know if you find one.

 

Thanks,

 

Bob & Moses

 

 

 

 

 

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

  • Share/Bookmark
Bob Beck on April 11th, 2011

It’s a piece of medical equipment that we really want to have inside the container when it ships on May 7th.  That’s less than a month from now so if you have any idea where there’s one that’s in good working order please let me know right now where it is and what we have to do to get it.

A CR Reader is something that reads x-rays and mammo images without developing an x-ray plate.  This doesn’t sound right but Moises tells me it cost the hospital more to develop an x-ray than it does to do a CT Scan.  A plate,much like the chip you have in your digital camera, only a lot bigger, is used instead of x-ray film.  When the X-ray is fired the image is captured by the CCD’s on the CR plate.  CCD’s are Charged Coupled Devices and CR means Computer Reader.  An exposed plate is placed into the CR Reader and volia!! the image is sent to a computer workstation.  From that workstation the image can be viewed by a doctor at Easter Maine, Rhode Island Hospital, UMASS, or Kansas City and doctors from those locations can look at the image when they are called in to consult on a case.

The hospital can do that, and is doing that, with the CT Scanner.  The goal is to be able to extend  the same level of diagnostic capability to the X-ray, Mammography, and Ultrasound machines.  Later this year we hope to replace the aging equipment but will still have need for the CR Reader.

In the US there are a lot of CR Readers due to radiology departments upgrading to an all digital system.  The challenge is to find one that has not been sold to an equipment dealer or traded in when the hospital or clinic upgraded to a digital system.  That’s where you can be a big help.  Just do some snooping around and maybe you’ll make the discovery of the year for the hospital.  There is a picture of a CR Unit but there are many models and they all don’t look like the photo.  The important question is what condition is it in, is it currently under a maintenance contract, and it MUST be able to read X-Ray and Mammography plates.  If you find a CR someplace, regardless of how well it fits the specs in the last sentence call me at 774-364-1335 or email me at rbeck.jr@gmail.com

So PLEASE get out your Sherlock Holmes, dust off those old scavenger hunt skills and go find one of these.

 

Thanks and good hunting

God Bless

Moises and Bob

 

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

  • Share/Bookmark
Bob Beck on April 8th, 2011

You have heard about Johanna.  Here’s a short clip sent in by Ginny Beal from KC.

 

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

  • Share/Bookmark
Bob Beck on April 6th, 2011

 

US SearchWe really need your help.  Please download the equipment list from the web site http://www.laromana.org/Hospital%20Equipment%20%20List.pdf

Or download the attachment here.        Hospital Equipment List

If you have a source or any leads or any questions please send an email to info@laromana.org

Time is of the essence.  We want to ship a container as soon as we can get it filled.

Please help.

 

Bob Beck

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

  • Share/Bookmark